Press "Enter" to skip to content

Mozart And The Mind

Mozart And The Mind Mozart and the Mind Music appears to be one of the fundamental activities of mankind. In nearly every country around the world people are dancing, singing, jiving, or chillin to their favorite tunes. There is just something about the variations of musical notes all mixed together that can alter the way we act, feel, and even think. It is generally agreed that music causes some kind of increased arousal in those who are the least bit interested in it and are listening with some degree of concentration. In depth studies have shown that music can reduce pain in childbirth, strengthen immune systems, and give surgery patients fewer complications with a much faster recovery (Take two 108).

The latest claim is that listening to classical music can enhance ones ability to reason abstractly, in turn boosting a person’s IQ (intelligence quotient). The question is, is the claim really valid? Astonishingly, this idea is taken as fact in most parts of America when really it is a theory based on much exaggeration. This idea of there being a link between classical music and a person’s IQ is commonly referred to as the Mozart Effect, a term coined by Alfred Tomatis. This was first suggested about six years ago by a group of researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh (Halpern 1). Using music as treatment for psychological or physical disorders is an idea that has existed in many forms, in many cultures, and for many centuries (Marwick 267). Well, so what. Music may play a role in how a person acts or feels.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

But does becoming smarter by listening to this same music fall along similar lines? Braddock 2 Some agree and others disagree; nevertheless they are basing their beliefs on three areas: experimental data, scientific research on the brain, or personal experiences. Among the many supporters of the Mozart Effect is the author of The Mozart Effect, Don Campbell. The Red Book magazine reports Campbell saying in his book that ‘music alters our energy patterns and affects all sorts of processes, from blood pressure and heartbeat to muscle tensions and brain waves’ (Take two 108). The main study of importance supporting Campbell’s claim came from a study done by researchers from the University of Wisconsin. This study consisted of several college students listening to Mozart’s Sonata of two pianos in D major for 10 minutes and then taking a specialized test (Weiss D5). The results showed that the students scored better on the tests after listening to the music, giving evidence of at least a temporary boost in IQ (D5). With studies like these surfacing, there is just to much evidence in support of the Mozart Effect for it to just be thrown away, yet the evidence presented from these same studies is not strong enough to persuade all.

So the controversy is now on the validity of studies like the one conducted by the researchers from the University of Wisconsin. These people in opposition believe that music has no relation with the way you think and how one may learn. The main arguments that the theory debunkers present have to do with the lack of scientific evidence the theory is currently holding its ground with. One strong argument against the Mozart Effect is that the only study taken tested one short piece of music: 10 minutes’ worth of Mozart’s Sonata for Two Pianos in D Major. The study said that, after listening to the music, subjects only experienced a Braddock 3 temporary boost in scores (Kolata 5).

So in fact the original research behind this attractive brain-altering notion said nothing about neither intelligence nor brain development. All it displayed was that a group of college students happened to do better on a battery of specialized tests shortly after listening to Mozart. Despite these claims there is still scientific research being done on music and its relationship to the mind including numerous laboratory experiments on animals and humans alike. Shown with an Electro-encephalogram, the changes of amplitude and frequency of the brain waves are evident. Therefore there is definitely something going on in the brain when musical notes vibrate through our ears, but the question of does it make a person smarter? is still present. Other neurologic studies are showing that the brain becomes active subconsciously in response to music.

In reaction to these studies some say, the brain is fundamentally programmed so that the organic connections are symphonic rather than mechanistic (Marwick 268). Meaning that by merely listening to music your brain can be better enhanced than by doing any type of physical activity. No doubt, there are scientific studies that have been done, and are still being pursued, many people believe these studies are biased with researchers designing experiments that will favor their belief. John Bruer, president of the McDonnell Foundation, based in St. Louis, Mo., argues that ‘much of what people are hearing about how the classical music will make one smarter is based on gross exaggerations of brain science’ (Lemonick 76).

Besides all the tests and studies there are also many people that believe in the Braddock 4 Mozart Effect due to their own personal experiences. Hundreds of mothers claim to notice unusual movement from their unborn babies when listening to the music and say that they can really tell the baby enjoys it, even though they can’t see it yet (Weiss D5). Although this may be true, Janet DiPietro states, in the San Francisco Chronicle, [‘just because the baby moved doesn’t mean it liked it. The kicking could also have been the baby’s way of saying, Turn it off!’] (Weiss D5). Hope Rose, president and founder of the Creative Movement and Arts Center, which uses music as a backdrop for children’s movement classes, stated that classical music stimulates young children’s minds and taps into their emotions (Weiss D5).

From personal experiences like these, governors such as Zell Miller from Georgia have been inspired to provide CDs to every new mother in the state (Goode 1). While, in Florida, a new law requires that toddlers in state-run schools listen to classical music every day (1). Using the opinions of highly respected people declaring that Music speaks to the entire human being, like Clive E. Robbins, PhD, director of the Nordoff-robbins Music Therapy Center at New York University, educational facilities are able to tie in the Mozart Effect into the curriculums of schools justly (Marwick 268). Other people are convinced that there is some sort of scandal going on involving big music companies and an Austrian composer, who died in 1791.

In this study, money seems to be the main motive for research. Music that will boost my IQ! Where?, is what many people are thi …

x

Hi!
I'm Charlotte

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out